Quick Answer: Compare To vs. Compare With
Both compare to and compare with are grammatically correct, but they can emphasize different kinds of comparisons.
- Compare to: Often used to highlight similarities between two different things, especially when one is likened to another.
- Compare with: Often used to examine two or more things side by side to identify similarities and differences.
Examples:
- Compare to: The poet compared her smile to sunshine.
- Compare with: Compare this year’s sales with last year’s figures.
In everyday English, the two expressions sometimes overlap. The best choice depends on the context and the meaning you want to convey.
What Does Compare To Mean?
The phrase compare to is commonly used when one person, object, or idea is likened to another because they share a particular quality.
It often appears in figurative language, descriptions, literature, and everyday speech. The purpose is frequently to emphasize a resemblance rather than conduct a detailed analysis.
Examples of Compare To in Sentences
- She compared his voice to the sound of thunder.
- The teacher compared the human brain to a computer.
- The author compared life to a journey.
- He compared the city lights to a blanket of stars.
- Her determination can be compared to that of a champion.
In these examples, compare to draws attention to a similarity between two things.
When Should You Use Compare To?
Use compare to when you want to:
- Make an analogy: Explain an unfamiliar concept through a familiar one.
- Create a vivid image: Use figurative language to help readers visualize an idea.
- Highlight a resemblance: Point out a shared quality between different things.
- Write literary descriptions: Make a sentence more expressive or memorable.
Example: The coach compared the team’s progress to a rising sun.
This comparison emphasizes the team’s improvement by likening it to the sun rising.
What Does Compare With Mean?
The phrase compare with is often used when examining two or more things to determine how they are similar or different.
It is particularly common in analytical, academic, scientific, and professional writing. The comparison may involve measurable details, characteristics, performance, quality, or results.
Examples of Compare With in Sentences
- Compare the two reports with each other before making a decision.
- Researchers compared the new treatment with the existing method.
- We compared this year’s expenses with last year’s budget.
- The editor compared the revised draft with the original version.
- You should compare the product’s features with those of its competitors.
In these sentences, compare with emphasizes examining items side by side.
When Should You Use Compare With?
Use compare with when you want to:
- Analyze differences: Identify how two things differ.
- Evaluate similarities: Examine shared features or qualities.
- Review data: Compare statistics, figures, or research results.
- Make informed decisions: Assess products, services, plans, or alternatives.
- Write analytical content: Explain how two subjects relate to one another.
Example: The company compared its quarterly profits with those of the previous year.
This sentence focuses on examining financial results across two periods.
Compare To vs. Compare With: Key Differences
The traditional distinction is that compare to emphasizes resemblance, while compare with emphasizes examination. However, modern English usage allows considerable overlap.
| Feature | Compare To | Compare With |
|---|---|---|
| Traditional emphasis | Similarity or resemblance | Similarities and differences |
| Common use | Analogies and figurative language | Analysis and evaluation |
| Writing style | Literary, descriptive, everyday | Academic, analytical, professional |
| Example | She compared the child to a butterfly. | She compared the two paintings with each other. |
| Is it grammatically correct? | Yes | Yes |
The distinction is a useful guideline, not an absolute rule. Context determines which expression sounds most natural.
Compare To vs. Compare With in Different Contexts
1. In Everyday Conversation
Both expressions can be used naturally in ordinary conversation.
- Compare to: This beach is often compared to a tropical paradise.
- Compare with: Compare this beach with the one we visited last summer.
The first sentence creates a resemblance. The second invites a more direct comparison between two beaches.
2. In Academic Writing
Compare with is often useful when discussing evidence, theories, research, or historical events.
Example: The researcher compared the survey results with data from an earlier study.
However, compare to can also be appropriate when explaining an analogy.
Example: The professor compared the structure of an atom to a miniature solar system.
3. In Business and Marketing
Business writing often uses compare with when evaluating performance, prices, or products.
Example: Customers can compare the subscription plans with one another before choosing an option.
Compare to may be used for descriptive or promotional analogies.
Example: The company compared its new service to a personal assistant.
4. In Literature and Creative Writing
Compare to is common when a writer wants to make a metaphorical or imaginative connection.
Example: The writer compared hope to a candle burning in the darkness.
Compare with can also appear in literary analysis when examining different works.
Example: The critic compared the novel with the author’s earlier work.
5. In Science and Research
Compare with is particularly useful when evaluating observations, experimental results, or methods.
Example: The scientists compared the experimental results with their original predictions.
The phrase indicates a direct examination of two sets of information.
Compare To vs. Compare With: Side-by-Side Examples
The following examples show how the intended meaning can affect your choice.
| Compare To | Compare With |
|---|---|
| He compared her eyes to the stars. | He compared her eyes with those of the other models. |
| The teacher compared learning to climbing a mountain. | The teacher compared the two students’ test results with each other. |
| The author compared the city to a living organism. | The author compared the city with other major urban centers. |
| She compared his courage to that of a lion. | She compared his performance with the team’s previous results. |
| The advertisement compared the car to a racing machine. | The reviewer compared the car with similar models. |
The to examples generally create analogies or highlight resemblances. The with examples more clearly suggest a side-by-side assessment.
Is Compare To or Compare With More Formal?
Neither expression is inherently more formal or more correct than the other.
Compare with is often a natural choice in technical, academic, and professional writing because these contexts frequently involve detailed analysis.
Compare to is common in literary, descriptive, and conversational contexts, especially when one thing is likened to another.
For formal writing, focus on clarity and context rather than assuming that one preposition is always superior.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Understanding the difference between these phrases can help you avoid several common errors.
1. Assuming They Always Mean Different Things
The traditional distinction is useful, but the expressions can overlap in modern English.
Better approach: Consider whether you are making an analogy or conducting a direct evaluation.
2. Using Compare To for Every Analytical Comparison
Although compare to is sometimes used broadly, compare with may communicate the idea of a systematic side-by-side examination more clearly.
Example:
Less precise: Compare this year’s figures to last year’s figures.
Clear alternative: Compare this year’s figures with last year’s figures.
The first sentence is not necessarily incorrect; the second simply emphasizes direct comparison.
3. Assuming Compare With Cannot Express Similarity
Compare with can identify similarities as well as differences. It does not mean that the items must be different.
Example: The reviewer compared the two novels with respect to their themes and found them remarkably similar.
4. Confusing Compare With and Compared To
Both phrases can be used with different verb forms.
- Present: We compare the results with the original data.
- Past: We compared the results with the original data.
- Passive: The results were compared with the original data.
Choose the verb tense that fits the sentence, and use the preposition that communicates your intended meaning.
5. Ignoring Context
Choosing a preposition based only on a memorized rule can sometimes make writing less natural.
Better approach: Read the complete sentence and determine whether the emphasis is on resemblance, evaluation, or both.
How to Remember the Difference
Use this simple memory aid:
- Compare to = liken: Think of comparing a person to a lion or life to a journey.
- Compare with = examine: Think of comparing prices, research results, or two versions of a document.
For example:
- “She compared his patience to that of a saint.” This emphasizes resemblance.
- “She compared his results with the other candidates’ results.” This emphasizes evaluation.
Remember that this is a helpful guideline rather than a strict grammatical law.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Is compare to or compare with correct?
Both are correct. Compare to often emphasizes similarities or analogies, while compare with often emphasizes examining similarities and differences.
2. What is the main difference between compare to and compare with?
The traditional difference is that compare to likens one thing to another, whereas compare with examines two things side by side. In modern English, their meanings sometimes overlap.
3. Should I use compare to or compare with in academic writing?
Compare with is often a good choice for academic analysis, particularly when examining research, data, theories, or historical events. Use compare to when an analogy is intended.
4. Is compare to grammatically incorrect?
No. Compare to is grammatically correct and widely used, especially in figurative comparisons and descriptions.
5. Can compare with show similarities?
Yes. Compare with can be used to identify similarities, differences, or both.
6. Which is better: compare this with that or compare this to that?
Both can be correct. Use compare this with that when emphasizing a side-by-side examination. Use compare this to that when emphasizing resemblance or making an analogy, while recognizing that everyday usage often overlaps.
7. Is compare to more common in American English?
Both expressions are common in American English. The choice usually depends more on the context and intended meaning than on a strict regional distinction.
8. Can compare to and compare with be used interchangeably?
Sometimes. In many everyday sentences, either preposition works without substantially changing the meaning. In other contexts, one phrase may communicate the intended relationship more clearly.
9. What is an example of compare to?
Example: “The speaker compared the challenge to climbing a steep mountain.”
This sentence uses an analogy to help the audience understand the challenge.
10. What is an example of compare with?
Example: “The manager compared the team’s current performance with its performance last quarter.”
This sentence describes an evaluation of two sets of results.
Conclusion
Both compare to and compare with are correct English expressions. The traditional guideline is simple: use compare to when you want to liken one thing to another, and use compare with when you want to examine things side by side.
However, the distinction is not absolute, and the phrases sometimes overlap in everyday usage. Rather than memorizing an inflexible rule, consider the meaning of your sentence and choose the expression that communicates your point clearly.
With practice, you can use both phrases confidently in academic writing, professional communication, and everyday conversation.